Prime Autos sued after secretly removing catalytic converter

On October 25, 2019, Whitney, LLP’s auto fraud lawyers filed a lawsuit against Prime Autos, LLC in Glen Burnie, MD, and its owner, Robert H. Tuck, on behalf our client, alleging Fraud, Fraudulent Concealment and violations of Maryland’s Consumer Protection Act arising out of the sale of a used 2008 Ford F-350. The following allegations are set forth in the complaint that was filed against Prime Autos, LLC and Robert H. Tuck in the Circuit Court for Anne Arundel County. Both Defendants may very well dispute some or all of what has been alleged.

Whitney, LLP’s consumer auto sales attorneys represent consumers in a variety of fraud, forgery, spot delivery, damaged car and false credit application information cases against new and used car dealerships across Maryland, including in Annapolis, Baltimore, Columbia, Germantown, Silver Spring, Frederick, Waldorf, Glen Burnie, Gaithersburg, Rockville, Ellicott City, Dundalk and Bethesda.  Consultations are always free. 

Contact us now at (410) 583-8000 or use our online Quick Contact Form.  Some of our auto fraud settlements from past cases can be reviewed here.

Used Truck Sale at Prime Autos

Our client  purchased the 2008 Ford F-350 in July 2019 as a gift for his son.  Maryland law requires that vehicles sold to consumers pass a safety inspection, known as the Maryland Safety Inspection. Within a week of the purchase, he noticed oil leaking from the vehicle in his driveway. After calling Prime Autos and speaking with an employee regarding the oil leak, he was informed he could take the vehicle to them, or to his own mechanic, to get an inspection and estimate on repairs. He decided to take the vehicle to his trusted mechanic, who found thousands of dollars of work that needed to be performed.  Even more unsettling was the discovery that the catalytic converter and EGR had been removed.

His mechanic informed him that the vehicle should not have passed the Maryland inspection without those items.

A vehicle without the catalytic converter and EGR will fail a Maryland inspection, and will fail subsequent Maryland emissions tests. The purpose of the catalytic converter is an emissions control device that converts the toxic gases and emissions from an automobile into harmless emissions. The purpose of an EGR is also to reduce harmful emissions from an automobile.

Prime Autos Secretly Removed the Truck’s Catalytic Converter

Our client  then filed a complaint with the Automotive Safety Enforcement Division of the Maryland State Police Inspection unit at the MVA in Glen Burnie. A few days later, he spoke with the assigned Maryland State Police Investigator, and then met the Investigator at the inspection facility where the Maryland inspection had been performed. The technician who performed the inspection on the vehicle insisted that the catalytic converter and EGR had been on the vehicle when the inspection was performed. The Maryland State Police Investigator then performed another Maryland inspection on the vehicle and failed it for the missing catalytic converter and EGR, as well as a steering problem.

On the same day after the Maryland State Police Investigator failed the vehicle, our client   drove to Prime Autos and spoke with Robert H. Tuck about the missing equipment. Our client alleges that Tuck told him that he had told his lot mechanic to remove the catalytic converter and EGR from the vehicle after it had passed the Maryland inspection, and that Tuck then said “everyone takes this stuff off.”

Tuck then told our client that they would either repair the vehicle or ask the auction house where the vehicle was purchased to buy the vehicle back, and if the auction house refused, he would buy it back instead.  He told our client to remove his items from the vehicle and leave it there, and our client agreed to do so.

Several weeks, and then months, passed, with a frustrating game of voicemails and back-and-forth with Prime Autos saying they would repair the vehicle, and then saying they would buy it back. On November 26, 2018,  our client drove by Prime Autos on his way to the MVA in Glen Burnie to file a complaint against Prime Autos, LLC due to their  ongoing delay.

To his surprise, as he drove by Prime Autos, he saw the vehicle parked on the lot and being advertised as “for sale” to the general public.  He stopped and took photographs of the vehicle, and was confronted by Defendants’ employees, who again said they would repair the vehicle.  Our client then continued to the MVA and filed a complaint against Prime Autos, LLC.  Our client also realized that despite purchasing the vehicle months ago, he had not received the title or registration.

Several weeks passed before our client was told by Prime Autos that vehicle was repaired.  However, the first day after getting it home, the engine light came back on, and our client   discovered that there was no transmission fluid or no oil in it.  Our client  then filled those fluids. Three days later, while driving the vehicle to the MVA in Glen Burnie to get the license plates for the vehicle, and then driving to a Ford dealership to have a comprehensive inspection performed on the vehicle, the vehicle lost power while being driven on I-695. Despite the vehicle failing, our client   managed to drive to the side of road and avoid a collision.  The vehicle would then not start. The vehicle was towed to the Ford dealership, where it was determined that, among other issues, an old, clogged catalytic converter had been installed onto the vehicle, and the clogged catalytic converter had caused the engine to fail.

Our client then had the vehicle towed to his home, where it sits, inoperable, while our client   is forced to make the payments on the loan to protect his credit rating.  After trying for months to resolve the problem, our client contacted Whitney, LLP and we accepted the case.  After evaluating the facts, it became apparent that our client had been tricked into purchasing a vehicle that could not pass the Maryland inspection due to the catalytic converter and EGR being secretly removed, and had been placed into serious danger due to faulty repairs causing the vehicle to stop working while driving on 695.  It is a miracle that our was not killed or seriously injured when that happened.

Prime Autos cited by MVA for Violating Maryland Law

After the MVA completed its investigation, it cited Prime Autos for multiple violation of the Maryland Transportation Code, listed below, and the bond was release. When a car dealer’s bond is released, that means the MVA provided the bond information to the customer, who may now make a claim against the bond.  Whitney, LLP assists consumers with bond claims against unlawful dealerships.

13-113(e)(2)(ii) Late titling,

15-312(b) Making Material Misrepresentations in obtaining Vehicle Sales Contract,

23-109(i) Prohibited Activities; and

15-314(g) Violation of Vehicle Laws.

Lawyers for Used Car and Truck Fraud Claims Against Prime Autos

If you have purchased a vehicle from PrimeAutos in Glen Burnie, Maryland you should immediately have the vehicle inspected to see if the catalytic converter or ERG was removed.  Or, if you had any other problems with your car or truck purchase there, including potential fraud, misrepresentations, damage, or other types of potential claims, contact Whitney, LLP to discuss your options.

Contact us now at (410) 583-8000 or use our online Quick Contact Form. Consultations are always free.